Whether or not you should buy a new or used car depends on your budget, how long you’re planning to keep the car, and how much the latest tech and warranty cover matter to you.
There's no single right answer. But to help you decide, this guide covers everything from depreciation and running costs to warranty and how the finance options differ between new and used cars.
Thinking about financing your car? Use our car finance calculator to get a good idea of the type of deal you might be offered.
The case for buying new
So, why buy a new car vs used? New cars have a few main advantages: a full manufacturer warranty, the latest safety and infotainment tech, no MOT needed for the first three years, and the ability to choose the specifications you want without compromising. Let’s look into these in more detail.
A manufacturer's warranty
New cars usually come with a manufacturer's warranty. This is usually around three years, although some manufacturers offer longer cover. This helps protect you against the cost of certain repairs if something goes wrong during the warranty period. Having that cover can give peace of mind and may help you avoid big unexpected repair bills during the first few years of ownership if the issue is covered by the warranty.
The latest safety and infotainment tech
New cars generally offer the latest infotainment systems that make driving smoother and easier. The same applies to safety technology. Depending on the new car you choose, you may be more likely to get features like adaptive cruise control, parking cameras and smartphone connectivity than in an older, used car.
No MOT for the first three years
In Great Britain, most new cars don't need their first MOT until the third anniversary of registration. You'll still need to maintain the car properly. Even though an MOT certificate isn’t needed, the car must still be kept in a safe, roadworthy condition.
Ability to choose the specification you want
When you buy a new car, you can often configure it with the exact specs you want. You can choose the colour, trim level, engine and other optional extras. Availability depends on the manufacturer and model, but you’re more able to build a car around your preferences rather than compromising on features.
The case for buying used
There are also several advantages to buying a used car over a new one. Used cars usually have a significantly lower purchase price, you may avoid absorbing the steep depreciation hit, you get a far wider choice for the same budget, and a nearly-new used car could still carry years of manufacturer warranty. Here are the main benefits to consider.
A lower purchase price
One of the biggest benefits of buying used is the lower cost. Used cars are generally cheaper to buy than new cars of the same model. This could mean you can afford a higher specification, a larger car or a model that would otherwise be outside your budget.
Less depreciation to absorb
Cars usually lose value as they age, and they lose the most in the first year. By buying used, you avoid paying the original new-car price and may avoid some of the steepest depreciation. The original owner will have taken the hit from the big initial drop. The amount you save typically depends on the car's age, mileage, condition and demand.
Here’s that explained in a bit more detail.
Depreciation - the single biggest factor
Depreciation is the main thing you need to think about when weighing up buying a new car vs a used car. A new car loses a significant chunk of its value the moment it's driven away, and continues depreciating fast in the first three years. Buying an older, used car means you could avoid taking that hit.
Cars often depreciate more slowly as they get older, although this varies by model. A used car that's around two to three years old might be a good option, because the initial depreciation has passed but it will have modern tech. Cars older than 5 years depreciate more slowly, but then you may have to compromise more on features and run the risk of paying for repairs.
Think about how long you plan to keep the car. If you want to sell it after a few years, choosing a model that holds its value could help reduce your overall costs. If you're planning to keep it for much longer, depreciation may matter less.
You can use our free car valuation tool to get an estimate of what a particular car could be worth.
Running costs beyond the purchase price
The purchase price is only one part of owning a car. Insurance and tax, maintenance and fuel or charging costs can all affect how much you spend over time:
Servicing and repairs: New cars may need fewer repairs in their early years, and the manufacturer's warranty could cover eligible faults. Older used cars may need more maintenance from parts wearing out, so be sure to check the service history and how well it's been looked after.
Road tax: Vehicle tax depends on the car’s registration date, emissions, fuel type and original list price. New cars usually include the first year’s tax in the price, while cars that were expensive when new pay an extra charge for five years from the second year, even if you buy them used. You can check the tax rate for the car you’re considering online.
Insurance: Insurance costs depend on factors including your age, location, driving history, annual mileage and the car's insurance group. A new car may cost more to insure because of its higher replacement value, but this isn't always the case.
MOT costs: Most new cars don't need their first MOT until they're three years old, while older used cars generally need annual tests. Remember to factor in the cost of the test, and have some money set aside for any repairs needed if the car fails the test.
Fuel and charging: Newer cars may offer better fuel economy or electric range than older equivalents. But this depends on the model and how you drive. If you're considering an electric or hybrid car, think about whether you can get access to home charging as this is much cheaper than rapid public charging.
When comparing the running costs of new cars vs used cars in the UK, look into these details for the specific models you're considering so you can compare them.
How financing a new car differs from financing a used car
New vs used car financing can differ in practice. Typically, PCP is more common for new cars and HP is a popular option for used cars.
PCP is especially common on new cars because payments are based on the car’s Guaranteed Future Value (GFV), rather than its full purchase price. Your monthly payments cover the difference between the car’s price and its estimated value at the end of the agreement (the GFV), plus interest. But if you want to keep the car at the end, you’ll need to pay the final balloon payment. If you buy a new car directly through a manufacturer’s dealership, you could be offered a manufacturer-backed PCP deal with a lower APR, subject to eligibility.
HP is a more common route for used cars because the finance is based on the purchase price, which is typically lower than for a new car. It’s a more straightforward form of finance. With HP, you spread this full cost of a car over your loan term, plus interest, and ownership transfers to you once all payments, including any option to purchase fee, are made.
The APR you’re offered can also depend on the car's age. Some lenders may charge higher interest rates for older cars, so a used car's lower purchase price doesn't always mean cheaper finance overall. That’s why it’s important to shop around and weigh up your options.
Need more information before deciding on a used car loan vs a new car loan? Read our guide to car finance explained.
Is leasing a new car better than buying a used one?
Car leasing - also known as Personal Contract Hire (PCH) – could be another option for a new car. With PCH, you pay to use the car for an agreed period and mileage limit, then return it at the end of the lease. PCH gives you access to a new car with fixed monthly costs and no resale hassle. However, you never own the car, and extra charges may apply if you exceed the mileage limit or return it with damage beyond fair wear and tear.
Buying a used car could offer better long-term value if ownership is important to you. You can buy it outright or may be able to use HP to spread the cost. This also gives you the freedom to keep it for as long as you like or sell it when you're ready.
Ultimately, leasing a new car vs buying used comes down to what matters most to you. Leasing may suit you if you value a newer car and predictable costs, while buying used may be better if you want to own your car and avoid ongoing monthly payments once it's paid off.
Work out the real cost for you
Use our car finance calculator to compare your estimated monthly costs of a new vs used car side by side. It’s free to use and you can get a good idea of the finance deal you may be offered, subject to status and lender approval.
Comparing the costs between the two can help you work out which option best suits your budget. Remember to consider more than the monthly payment and think about the long-term costs too.
Conclusion
There’s no universally right answer when deciding whether to buy a new or used car. A new car may suit you if you prioritise warranty cover, the latest technology, more choice over specifications and fewer age-related repairs. A used car may be better if you want a lower purchase price and to avoid the steepest depreciation.
Think about the overall cost of owning the car, as well as the purchase price. Insurance, road tax, servicing, repairs and fuel or charging can all affect what you spend over time. An older used car may cost more to maintain, while a new car could cost more to buy and insure.
How you finance a new vs used car is worth comparing just as carefully as the cars themselves. PCP is common for new cars, while HP is a popular option for used cars if you want to own it once all the payments are made. But you could get PCP on eligible used cars and HP on new cars too, so it’s important to weigh up which one suits your budget and priorities best.
-
Can I get PCP finance on a used car?
Yes, you could get PCP finance on a used car with Car Finance 247, subject to status. Eligibility depends on the vehicle, the lender and your affordability but we’ll do our best to find you a deal.
-
How much value does a new car lose in the first year?
A new car can lose a significant share of its value in the first year. The amount varies by make, model, mileage and market demand. This is the steepest period of depreciation, which is why buying a used car could help you avoid some of that initial drop.
-
Is leasing a new car cheaper than buying a used one?
Leasing can sometimes mean lower monthly payments, depending on the car, term, mileage allowance and deposit. However, you won't ever own the leased car, and you'll need to keep paying to drive another one. Buying used may cost more each month in some cases, but you can own the car once your finance is paid off.
-
Is it cheaper to finance a new car or a used car?
Financing a used car can be cheaper overall because the purchase price is typically lower. However, if you buy directly through a manufacturer’s dealership, new cars can sometimes come with manufacturer-backed deals that could lower the interest you pay. The APR can make a big difference too, as a higher APR could increase the overall cost of a used car, even with a lower purchase price. That’s why it’s important to compare deals.